In a seed-stage round, the shareholders’ agreement is where much of the future relationship is decided, even though the company is small. The investor’s objective is usually to protect their investment and ensure clear exit rules. The founding team’s objective is to preserve operational agility and avoid being blocked on day-to-day decisions. Good negotiation does not consist of “winning” every clause, but of establishing reasonable protections with clear thresholds, so that governance does not become an obstacle.
Three concepts usually concentrate the tension: vetoes, drag-along and tag-along. A veto is a right to block decisions. It is legitimate if applied to extraordinary matters that can change the value of the investment, but it is harmful if it extends to micromanagement. Drag-along is the rule that allows a majority to force the rest to sell if an offer arises, preventing a minority from blocking an exit. Tag-along protects minorities by allowing them to sell on the same terms if the majorities sell.
Before negotiating, it is advisable to have a simple criterion: operational decisions are made quickly, structural decisions are made by consensus. This criterion translates into thresholds and closed lists. If you accept vetoes, let them be over a short list of matters and always with quantitative thresholds. For example, debt above an agreed amount, sale of essential assets, capital increases, change of business activity, dividend distributions or hiring of key personnel with remuneration outside the range. On the other hand, vetoes over detailed budgets, ordinary hiring or commercial decisions are a red flag: they turn the investor into a de facto manager.
In drag-along and tag-along, the danger usually lies in the percentages and conditions. A reasonable drag-along requires a qualified majority, for example, a high percentage of capital, and that the sale be to a third party on market terms. It is also common to require a minimum price or that the investor achieves a minimum return, but in seed stage this must be balanced so as not to block a real exit opportunity. Tag-along must ensure that, if a sale takes place, everyone can sell proportionally and on equal terms, avoiding “two-speed” sales.
Finally, put two safeguards in writing: that any veto list is closed and that every “material” term has a numerical definition or examples. Agility is not defended with phrases, it is defended with thresholds. In this way, the investor remains protected on the important matters and the company retains the capacity to execute, which is what ultimately grows the value of the investment.
The professional support of the Galicia Economic Office can make all the difference when launching an initiative. Access their free advice and make the most of the available tools.
